Divorce Cases, Lacking A Right Or Wrong, Toughest For Judges
Guest Author, Anne Kass, - a retired District Judge of Albuquerque, New Mexico

I was talking with a judge from South Carolina a few weeks go about an interstate custody problem. When I told him that I hear only family law cases, he said: "How in the world do you stand it? I find after hearing a few divorce cases, I need to hear a friendly first degree murder case or two to regain my sanity." A number of judges have told me they'd sooner preside over grisly criminal cases than divorce or custody suits.

I think the reason so many judges don't like to decide divorce cases (and the reason so many lawyers won't even accept divorce cases) is the fact that in so many divorce and custody cases, both sides are absolutely right.

Lawyers and judges are trained to concentrate on the past and to think in terms of right and wrong. An automobile collision occurred--whose fault was it? A contract has not been honored --who's to blame? A crime has been committed--who should be punished?

Non-lawyers, too, tend to assume that if there is a disagreement, one side must be right, the other wrong. And, in our litigious society, all manner of disagreements are taken to lawyers, who enhance the supposition that there is a right and a wrong.

What gives judges and lawyers such a hard time is the fact their right/wrong training and analyses are rarely applicable to or useful in divorce and custody suits.

How can it be wrong for each parent to want custody of their children? It seems absolutely right for both mother and father to want to spend as much time with the children as possible.

In almost all cases I see, if one parent says "I need more money," they are absolutely right--they do. And the parent who says, "I can't afford to pay more money," is undeniably right--they can't.

When one parent wants to move from New Mexico and take the children along, they usually have good, sensible reasons. They want to move back to where their families are; they want to move to accept a better-paying job. They're right. And the parent who is left behind says: "I want to see the children often, and I can't if they live in another state. I need to spend time with the children and they need to spend time with me." And they're right.

Many divorcing people leave the court system feeling that the system is unfair or that the Judge was biased or stupid or just didn't listen. Their feelings stem from the fact that what they asked for was fair or needed or logical--it was right. They reason that if what one requests is "right", how can a fair court system fail to say "you win". They fail to recognize that the problems stem from the fact that the other side was right too.

I believe it is essential for our legal system to educate the judges, the lawyers and the public that a disagreement does not necessarily mean one side is right, the other wrong. Right/Wrong law suits are easy to resolve. It's the right/right disputes that are hard--hard for lawyers to present, and hard for judges to decide, and harder yet for the parties to accept.

For more Anne Kass articles, go here to select from complete list of 97 articles

For listing of over 200 helpful staff articles on Divorce, go here


Tell Your Divorced Or Widowed Friends About This Article And Site, Send Them This Page Or If They Do Not Have A PC, Print Out The Article For Them
Divorce Cases, Lacking A Right Or Wrong, Toughest For Judges
Send this article to a friend
Read over 300 "Life Changing" recovery articles, click here

Top of Page ||  Divorce Recovery 101 Index

Recovery 101 .com
Divorce Recovery Support Group With Divorce Help, Advice, Tips, Divorce Law, Statistics And Information

Divorce Adjustment Help

Divorce Recovery Site Map
Divorce Recovery
Site Map

Divorce Questions and Answers

Divorce Questions
& Answers
Read and/or Submit

Personal Message?
Personal Message?

Online Support Friends Singles Chat
Online Support Friends Singles Chat

Free Divorce Newsletter
Free Divorce Newsletter
Sign Up Here

Free 5 Day Email Divorce Course
Free 5 Day Email Divorce Course
Sign Up Here

 Life Changing Recovery Articles
Read and Study over 300 "Life Changing" recovery articles, click here

Privacy Policy Reprint Our Articles
Reprint Our Articles
Information Here

1000 Helpful Single Life Links
1000 Helpful Single Life Links
go here

About Us
About Us
go here

Feel free to make suggestions
Please tell us how we are doing.
Feel free to make suggestions
Do it here

Help Others Find This Link To Us
How To Link To Us
Help Others Find This Site

Send This Page to "Divorcing Friends"
Send This Page to "Divorcing Friends",
easy form

Read Letters From Divorced Folks
Read Letters From Divorced Folks Like Yourself,
Read Mail

working on a great  as a single person
Single Life Coach  
is our site for those worked thru their divorce and are working on a great new life as a single person

Dating Again 101

Dating Again 101 is our new site for help in getting back into the dating world successfully

Free Dating Again newsletter edited by Harlan Jacobsen
Sign up for 
Free Dating Again newsletter of tips to help make new  relationships a part of your life. Edited by Harlan.

Search Articles
by keyword

Search our site:

search tips

search all 7 sites