Two Rights Make Decision Tougher
Guest Author, Anne Kass, - a retired District Judge of Albuquerque, New Mexico

Who gets custody when both parents are good?

People who come to my court with disputes or disagreements almost always have the notion that one of them is right and the other is wrong.

The judge's job is to figure out which is which, and to reward the one who's right and punish the one who's wrong. Right and wrong are what courts are all about.

In December 1987, a case was in my court that showed me how inappropriate right/wrong analyses are in divorce cases. The case went as follows.

Each person was 19. They had not been married, but they were the parents of a 2-month-old-child.

Neither had any post-high-school education or training. Their earning capacities were at minimum wage--then $3.35 an hour.

Their take-home pay was about $475 a month each. Day care cost $200 a month. Obviously, neither could survive alone.

The case was in court because the young mother wanted to return to Wyoming to live with her parents and she wanted to take the baby. The young father, who was also living with his parents, in Albuquerque, dearly loved the child, and he was a wonderful parent, as was the mother.

He did not want the child to leave New Mexico for obvious reasons.

As you can see, it was a very difficult case to decide, but I found myself agonizing about it much more than usual.

I wondered why this case seemed so much harder than any other I had seen. Then I realized why, and it was this:

Both of the young parents had been so wonderful. They had been nice to each other. They had been polite to their respective parents, their child's grandparents. They had been courteous to the court. And they were both so absolutely right about what they wanted.

It dawned on me that in most cases I see, the disputing individuals tend to misbehave to some degree. They tend to adopt the eye-for-an-eye approach, forgetting how true the old proverb that two wrongs never make a right is.

I realized also that my legal education and training had been to analyze cases from a right-or-wrong frame of reference.

Because most disagreeing parties behave badly, in most cases a decision can be based, or justified (perhaps rationalized), on a right/wrong foundation.

In this case, however, there wasn't a smidgen of wrong to be found.

The child went with its mother, because the grandparents at that home could take care of the child during the day, when the mother was at work.

The lesson I learned from that case is that in divorce cases, most disputes are right/right problems. There is usually enough misbehavior or "wrong" to go around, but when one peels away the layers of misbehavior and looks at what each party wants, one finds that each party is basically right.

It is right for both parents to want custody of a child or to want to spend as much time as possible with a child. And when one party says she or he can't afford to pay more money, she or he is generally right.

I find this right/right lesson to have been one of the most valuable and useful lessons I've yet learned as a judge.

For more Anne Kass articles, go here to select from complete list of 97 articles

For listing of over 200 helpful staff articles on Divorce, go here



Tell Your Divorced Or Widowed Friends About This Article And Site, Send Them This Page Or If They Do Not Have A PC, Print Out The Article For Them
Two Rights Make Decision Tougher
Send this article to a friend
Read over 300 "Life Changing" recovery articles, click here

Top of Page ||  Divorce Recovery 101 Index

Recovery 101 .com
Divorce Recovery Support Group With Divorce Help, Advice, Tips, Divorce Law, Statistics And Information

Divorce Adjustment Help

Divorce Recovery Site Map
Divorce Recovery
Site Map

Divorce Questions and Answers

Divorce Questions
& Answers
Read and/or Submit

Personal Message?
Personal Message?

Online Support Friends Singles Chat
Online Support Friends Singles Chat

Free Divorce Newsletter
Free Divorce Newsletter
Sign Up Here

Free 5 Day Email Divorce Course
Free 5 Day Email Divorce Course
Sign Up Here

 Life Changing Recovery Articles
Read and Study over 300 "Life Changing" recovery articles, click here

Privacy Policy Reprint Our Articles
Reprint Our Articles
Information Here

1000 Helpful Single Life Links
1000 Helpful Single Life Links
go here

About Us
About Us
go here

Feel free to make suggestions
Please tell us how we are doing.
Feel free to make suggestions
Do it here

Help Others Find This Link To Us
How To Link To Us
Help Others Find This Site

Send This Page to "Divorcing Friends"
Send This Page to "Divorcing Friends",
easy form

Read Letters From Divorced Folks
Read Letters From Divorced Folks Like Yourself,
Read Mail

working on a great  as a single person
Single Life Coach  
is our site for those worked thru their divorce and are working on a great new life as a single person

Dating Again 101

Dating Again 101 is our new site for help in getting back into the dating world successfully

Free Dating Again newsletter edited by Harlan Jacobsen
Sign up for 
Free Dating Again newsletter of tips to help make new  relationships a part of your life. Edited by Harlan.

Search Articles
by keyword

Search our site:

search tips

search all 7 sites